The Menhaden Hotel

The Menhaden Hotel - A 16-room boutique hotel with a rooftop bar, private water taxi, and proximity to Greenport's maritime landmarks

The Menhaden Hotel, a 4-star boutique property with a 9.5/10 rating on Booking.com, features 16 airy accommodations blending a neutral palette with wood and greenery accents. Guests can enjoy exclusive private experiences, including custom wine tours and oyster shucking classes on the rooftop deck, which offers views of Greenport Harbor and Shelter Island. The hotel's Mediterranean eatery, The Merchant's Wife, serves small plates in a modern setting, while each floor's galley kitchen provides complimentary local snacks and pastries. Located in Greenport Village, The Menhaden is within walking distance of the Long Island Railroad and landmarks like the Railroad Museum of Long Island (0.5 km). The concierge can arrange vineyard visits, beach picnics, or use of the hotel's complimentary bikes or Moke vehicle.

Pros

Greenport's only rooftop bar with firepits and harbor views.

Pet-friendly rooms available (under 25 lbs, one per room).

Complimentary amenities include beach chairs, bikes, and on-site parking.

Proximity to wineries, the Peconic River, and historic downtown Greenport.

Cons

Limited on-site parking (first-come, first-served).

Additional fees for extra guests in rooms ($250 per adult over two).